Astonishing X-Men: Xenogenesis #3

[Sentinel119]

Before I go on about the negatives of this book/story let me say that it is a great story that reminds me of Captain Britain. That said, I feel that this was a leftover Excalibur story that Ellis just retooled to fit with the Astonishing X-Men. It seems like Emma should be Rachel, Cyclops should be either Nightcrawler, Storm should be Meggan, Wolverine should by Kylun, and Beast should be Captain Britain. I wish I could have seen this story with those characters. It would have been so much better.

[curiouswanderer]

I haven't been very impressed with this series at all. Even this issue the art just really took a downhill turn. An interesting idea that's playing out rather tamely.

[Sentinel119]

I haven't been very impressed with this series at all. Even this issue the art just really took a downhill turn. An interesting idea that's playing out rather tamely.

curiouswanderer

I think that the problem is due to it being a repackaged idea.